1045 vs 4140 Steel
1045 is a plain medium-carbon steel: about 0.45% carbon plus manganese, nothing else. 4140 has a little less carbon but adds about 1% chromium and 0.2% molybdenum, and that alloy content is the whole story. Both can be quenched and tempered, but 1045 hardens through only thin sections, and only with a severe water quench, while 4140 hardens in oil through sections of 50 mm (2 in) and more. As bought, cold-drawn 1045 actually has a higher yield strength than annealed 4140; after heat treatment 4140 is far stronger and tougher.
Use 1045 for moderately loaded shafts, pins, axles and bolts where cold-drawn strength is enough, or where a hard wear surface is added by induction hardening. Use 4140 when the part must be strong through its section, when it will be bought pre-hardened and machined to size, or when it will be nitrided.
| Property | 1045 | 4140 |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Medium-carbon steel | Chromium-molybdenum alloy steel |
| Carbon | 0.43-0.50% | 0.38-0.43% |
| Other alloying | Mn 0.60-0.90% | Mn 0.75-1.00%, Cr 0.80-1.10%, Mo 0.15-0.25% |
| Tensile, as bought | 625 MPa (91 ksi), cold drawn | ~655 MPa (95 ksi) annealed; ~1000 MPa (145 ksi) at 28-32 HRC |
| Yield, as bought | 530 MPa (77 ksi), cold drawn | ~415 MPa (60 ksi) annealed; ~900 MPa (130 ksi) at 28-32 HRC |
| Hardness, as bought | ~180 HB cold drawn | ~197 HB annealed; 28-32 HRC pre-hard |
| Through-hardening | Shallow; water quench, thin sections only | Oil quench, through roughly 50-75 mm |
| Surface hardening | Induction or flame to ~55-60 HRC | Induction to ~50-55 HRC; nitrides well |
| Machinability (1212 = 100%) | ~55-60% cold drawn | ~65% annealed; slower at 28-32 HRC |
| Density | 7.85 g/cm³ | 7.85 g/cm³ |
| Typical uses | Shafts, pins, axles, bolts, induction-hardened rods and gears | Highly stressed shafts, gears, spindles, tooling, fixtures |
Typical values for the stated conditions. Confirm against the mill certificate and your spec.
Need a 1045 or 4140 part made?
- Welding & Fabrication companies that work with carbon steel · 172
- Finishing & Heat Treating companies that work with carbon steel · 95
- Machine shops that work with carbon steel · 89
- All U.S. manufacturers working with carbon steel · 366
- Find steel suppliers
- Machine shops that work with alloy steel · 30
- Forging companies that work with alloy steel · 11
- All U.S. manufacturers working with alloy steel · 78
Attach a drawing (PDF or STEP) or describe the part; a U.S. shop that fits quotes it.
Decision matrix
A check marks the side with the edge on that dimension.
| Dimension | 1045 | 4140 |
|---|---|---|
| Machining | Good; cold-drawn bar cuts cleanly | Good annealed; fair at 28-32 HRC pre-hard, slower feeds |
| Welding | ✓ Fair; preheat about 150-250 °C, low-hydrogen filler | Fair to poor; preheat, low-hydrogen filler and a post-weld temper |
| Forming | Fair; hot forged or formed | Fair annealed; hot forging common |
| Strength | Moderate; high only at an induction-hardened surface | ✓ Up to ~1500 MPa tensile Q&T through the section |
| Corrosion resistance | Poor; rusts, protect it | Poor; rusts, protect it |
| Finishing | Black oxide, plating, paint; nitrocarburizes, but gas nitriding adds little hardness | ✓ Black oxide, plating, paint; gas or ion nitrides to a hard case |
| Material cost | ✓ Lower; plain carbon steel | Higher; chromium and molybdenum add an alloy premium |
| Availability | Cold-drawn and turned-and-polished bar, plate, chrome-plated shafting | Bar and plate, annealed and pre-hard, everywhere |
Choose 1045 when
- Shafts, pins, axles and bolts at moderate stress, where cold-drawn strength is enough
- An induction- or flame-hardened wear surface over a soft core at the lowest material cost
- Parts that will be welded, since the lower carbon equivalent needs less preheat
- High-volume turned parts where the price per pound drives the quote
Choose 4140 when
- Sections thicker than about 15-25 mm (0.6-1 in) that must be hard through the core
- Fatigue- or impact-loaded shafts, gears, spindles and tooling
- Pre-hardened 28-32 HRC bar machined to size with no heat treat afterward
- Gas or ion nitriding for a hard, wear-resistant case
Frequently asked questions
- Is 4140 stronger than 1045?
- After heat treatment, yes, by a wide margin and through a much thicker section. As bought it depends on the condition: cold-drawn 1045 has about 530 MPa (77 ksi) yield, more than annealed 4140 at about 415 MPa (60 ksi). Pre-hardened 4140 at 28-32 HRC is around 900 MPa (130 ksi) yield.
- Can 1045 steel be hardened?
- Yes. It can be water or brine quenched and tempered, but it hardens fully only in thin sections and the severe quench risks distortion and cracking. The more common route is induction or flame hardening the surface to about 55-60 HRC while the core stays tough. For through-hardened parts, use 4140.
- Can you weld 1045 steel?
- Yes, with care. Preheat to roughly 150-250 °C depending on thickness, use low-hydrogen filler and cool slowly. It is easier than 4140, which needs similar or higher preheat plus a post-weld temper, but neither welds as freely as 1018 or A36.
- Which is cheaper, 1045 or 4140?
- 1045, per pound, because it carries no chromium or molybdenum. The gap can close on the finished part: pre-hardened 4140 skips a heat-treat step, while 1045 needs a separate hardening operation if the part must be strong.
